原帖由
有heart人 於 2008-11-20 08:57 PM 發表
well not sure if you want to point to me or not but I guess I am not against Bro G wor. in fact, I just answer his another post about his project to give him
input.
as for you comment.. ...
I apology if you found my previous reply offensive. Let me make it clear that I have no intention to point my finger at anyone or against anyone whatsoever. I just thought this is an open discussion forum, anyone can express his/her opinions on any post, if your post carries some “private” message to “Bro G” and for his eyes only, please excuse me for my intrusion, just like the other members who have posted their replies here, I am trying to express my point of view!
I am trying to point out the fact that there’s NO way you can tell who is the original builder of any model project posted, and I simply don’t think this is the policy of the HKML to verify that as well (they simply can’t, can you?). Post 2 completed kits and you got the green light to the trading area, that’s the rules, I don’t require to declare the those 2 kits were built by me, right? So why worry? Again, what’s the BIG deal (kicks) to get into the trading area, don’t you think you are exaggerate things?
I don’t know “Bro G” personally, so I will have no ideas whether or not he know (or will) build any model kit, I wonder how you people get the knowledge that “Bro G” is not the builder of those posted model projects. If the information are from “Bro G”, then he is, as I said, got ass-kicked for being a honest person!
I am sorry that I am unable to share your vision on “…I can foresee these kind of "other people's works" can be anything low in quality. I don't want to see HKML flooded with those posts and degraded the forum….”
I found it a little difficult to understand your saying “…I am not against “Bro G” as he posted out some cool works but you can't guarantee others will do the same,..”
You are saying if he post something “Cool”, you will have no objection, if not “Cool”, then you will have something to say, is my interpretation right?
I think the fundamental principal for HKML is for modelers to share their works and ideas, there should have no requirements on the “quality”. If you tell me HKML only accept high quality items, I will simply withdraw my membership as I don’t think I will be qualify for that! BTW, I would like hear your opinion on how to tell what kinds of works are “low in quality” and will “degrade” the forum?
I am not a serious modeler so HKML is the only model forum I’ve ever visited, thank you for your information stating the fact that “Bro G” can’t post in certain section, but are you saying we should do the same as the “other model building forums”? Why can’t we make a difference. As I said earlier, a model project is a model project, who built it doesn’t matter, as long as it got proper authorization and avoid duplicate posting.
I appreciate your “居安思危” thoughts, but I think you are worry too much and perhaps it clouded your judgments.
Anyway, it’s been a nice experience sharing with you, thanks!